Both the bust of Commodus as Hercules and the bust of Caracalla tell us a great deal about the character of the muse/subject portrayed. Both Commodus and Caracalla where emperors of Rome, although from the contrast of their depictions I can assume that they lived and ruled by very different means. Commodus appears at ease, arrogant, and privileged; Caracalla appears tense, powerful, and militaristic. These sculptures and the propagandist message they convey are easily read. They have a clear message even when isolating their facial expression; Commodus has a smug smile and relaxed brow, while Caracalla’s face is so tense it seems that every facial muscle must be flexed, even the eyes are shadowed and threatening.
In my opinion, Commodus’s bust is overly extravagant, and it makes the leader seem so incredible that he looses credibility. It is too much, and he seems to be compensating for something. According to our text he is posing as Hercules and at times claimed to be his reincarnation along with the incarnation of the god Juniper. Supposedly, Commodus not a great leader in any aspect and was very self indulgent, a trait that caries over to the design of his bust. He was obviously trying to convey his own greatness in every aspect that may have been desirable to Romans at the time. He is portrayed as a very strong, handsome figure, with defined muscles and detailed hair(the tidiness of his locks signify to me a life of ease, and pampering).There is a small figure of a man kneeling in front of him which makes him seem more powerful, like a beloved ruler. He is dressed as Hercules to convey strength in character and physicality, which seem unnatural and contradictory to his smug, leisurely facial expression. He seems at ease as if the life was easy and he had nothing to do; his eyes are only half open making this easy,even more pronounced. His is also holding apples from the Garden of Hesperides signifying immortality, again I feel he wanted to be perceived as the ultimate Roman ruler by embodying all the desirable qualities of the time.
While Commodus comes to us lavishly dressed to impress, Caracalla impresses us with nothing more than the intensity of his facial expression. The message is clear, as my three year old daughter put it “that is an angry man”. The bust of Caracalla does not use any props or suggestive figures to enhance the message of power, or prestige. In fact, he appears to me as a soldier due to his short hair and scruffy moustache. He also has a five o’clock shadow of sorts which makes him seem common, unlike the manicured curls of Commodus’s beard and hair. What really speaks to me about this sculpture, and I think it speaks to everyone this way, is tension in the face and the dark stare of the emperor. The shadow that falls from his intensely furrowed brow is imposing, makes his appear fierce, determined and even without a muscular body causes the viewer to assume that this is a man of great strength, leadership and superiority. Every muscle in the face seems tight,even the chin seems drawn in towards his tightly closed mouth, this aspect of the bust is very different from the smooth contours, and ease that we saw on Commodus.
I believe that both sculptures have a propagadistic message that can be widely understood. I also believe that while Commodus’s bust was attempting to convey a leader of strength, beauty, and immortality, it’s extravagance made these character traits seem as mythical as the apples of immortality that he held in his left hand. However, through the simplicity and bluntness of his bust Caracalla conveyed a very believable message that he was a fierce, powerful, and determined leader.
Painting Greek Sculpture
It is hard to say whether we naturally find beauty in the purity of a solid white sculpture, or if we have just been programed that way by our society, and particularly the views promoted by art Historian, Johann Joachim Winckelmann. Winkelmann loved Greek art for its simplicity; he found the pureness of the white sculptures naturalistic and beautiful. However, Winkelmann was unaware of the fact that many Greek sculptures were painted with vibrant colors that to the Greeks enhanced their naturalism. For whatever reason, I think that we are programmed to be more attracted to Winkelmann’s perception of Greek art; We are attracted to purity and see the paleness, and muscularity of Greek sculptures as naturalistic, and beautiful.
When Winkelmann looked at the sculptures he saw something that was intentionally white, and as the constant color of the marble illuminates details like muscularity, and facial features, it does seem naturalistic. I never knew Greek sculptures were painted and have always found them very beautiful, natural, and pure. When I was faced with the color sculpture of the Archer I was disappointed and unsure. The colors seemed so out of place with the perception I already had of Greek art. It seemed the paint (primary colors) was stealing the figures elegance and naturalism, morphing it into a bright, cartoonish figure, cheapening it a little. It kind of seemed like someone had gone in and violated the piece. However, after wrapping my head around the intention of the Greeks to use color as a naturalistic element (it is not a black and white world after all), I was able to see things differently. The intention of the artist was something that Winklemann was unaware of and perhaps if he had been aware of it he would have had different ideas about the color in its relation to purity, beauty, and naturalism.
For me both painted and unpainted are very beautiful. I still find more beauty and naturalism in the unpainted figures. I think it is because I can see the smoothness of the stone, contours of the muscle and subtleties of the face better without paint. Although, some of the painted figures stood out as naturalistic to me especially the red-hued Peplose Kore. The yellow dressed Kore didn’t seem as naturalistic, the colors were so bold and the hair was so dark making the face seem porcelain. The red-hued kore seemed more naturalistic than the unpainted version. I think the pink tint of the skin, along with colors of similar value, make the figure seem more natural.
Of course our perceptions have been formed by society and historians, but they have also been broadened by society and historians. I now have a new understanding of Greek art and find it beautiful, and naturalistic in both forms, painted or unpainted.
Egyptian Art
Egyptian art is characterized by strict artistic conventions and a very recognizable form causing me to question the creativity put into the making of these ancient works. The conventions used in Egyptian art were very systematic and stable, and they remained so for a long time. Due to this systematic and consistent representation of characters/scenes, and also the religious function of the art, I feel there is not a significant amount of creativity that goes into the art of ancient Egypt, at least for the individual artist. However I think it was collectively a very creative way of portraying and preserving life, seeing as it is very conceptual and stylized. There are also some Egyptian forms that I see more creativity in, specifically the sculptures of scribes and servants which seem more personalized.
In Egyptian art there are certain conventions and in some cases codes for layout, proportions, overall composition. The human body on a flat surface like a wall painting or relief typically shows the side profile of a face, torso turned out in full view while the legs remain silhouetted and usually in stride. This style is how we see all the figures from rulers to slaves; the main thing that sets the two apart is typically size and composition, with the king/god above or larger than the other figures. The importance of preserving history and themselves in the context of their religious beliefs in the afterlife, created this need for a systematic portrayal. Art was, in a sense, a big part of their religion. In some of the carvings and paintings they used the aid of mathematics and grids to layout their scenes, and transpose them from small scale to large scale. There were also rigid outlines for sculpting, such as seated rulers always having their hands placed on their laps. Most rulers were idealized with youthful, healthy forms not as lifelike as those other members of society. There are many other recognizable forms or codes that repeat themselves over and over in Egyptian art; the gods are characterized by sometimes having the heads of animals (still in side profile) the bodies of men, rulers are characterized by the shape of their helmets and such. Through codifying images a kind of language was created, allowing someone that is viewing the art to gain an understanding of the history, the time line of events and importance of various characters. It is easy to interpret because it is so uniform and familiar.
Due to the conventions imposed, the religious function, and the fact that most of this may have been ordered upon others to create leads me to the conclusion that creativity was not a priority for most Egyptian artists. However, I think that portraying the figures in the way of the Egyptians, their style, and dimensions, is very creative! I just think that for the individual artist it seems to be too functional, too produced to involve much creativity. Although, I noticed some pieces that seemed to break from the conventions and in doing so feel more creative. Looking at the carving of the “Seated Scribe” I see a very lively life like representation. It seems very creative to me because of the life like eyes the realistic representation of the ribs and abdomen. Also, the inscription “become a scribe so that your limbs remain smooth and your hands soft and you can wear white and walk like a man of standing whom [even] courtiers will greet” (60), makes the figure seem very personal. So as a whole I would say that Egyptian art does not exclude creativity, but limits it in most aspects through strict convention, religious purpose, and readability.
The Votive Statue of Gudea: A Formal Analysis
When looking at the votive statue of Gudea, we are confronted with a regal image of servitude and sustainability. This two and a half foot statue made in the votive style, signifies devotion and worship with eyes cast to the gods (or goddess as many interpretations suggest). The Statue is made out of diorite which is not an easy material for carving. There were many made like this one, suggesting the importance of the figure, Gudea, who was a ruler in southern Mesopotamian 2144-2124 BC. The hardness of the material has a significant impact of the detail of the carving; the creator had to choose what elements to accentuate texturally and such. Which makes it easy to assume that the water flowing from a vase held tightly by this stout, muscular figure is of great importance. The texture of the water that flows down from the vessel is very stylized with fish jumping in the water that flows past the statues feet and spills onto the surrounding area. This leads me to perceive this devoted figure as a provider.
The figure is made in the votive style, however unlike many votive statues, He is carrying something in his hands. By contextualizing the figure as a votive, or worship item, this addition could either be taken as an offering or gift from the gods. The way that the flowing water is engulfing the figure and falling on the floor around the votive suggests that is a gift, perhaps to the people of Mesopotamia. This display of resources, in companionship with the look of devotion on the statues face places Gudea as a intermediary position between god, and mortal.
In spite of the figures size, it has a strong powerful presence that I am sure is felt more intensely when in its presence. While it is not imposing in scale the muscles on the shoulders and forearms are exaggerated, and the texture given to the head piece suggest a regal position. Furthermore, the inscriptions made on the front of the gown, even without knowing the meaning, tell the viewer that Gudea was in a commanding role. Many votive statues held inscriptions of things that the one personified had done in honor of the gods. Knowing this, the statue of Gudea appears very devoted, commanding and accomplished.
Another interesting aspect of the composition of this piece is the disproportionately large upper body and head. This was a predominate style in many votive statues and other statues from Mesopotamia around this time period. This abnormal proportion draws attention to the face, chest and shoulders. Showing strength, strain, and attention the eyes are peeled widely open, looking up. The arms of this votive are tense, the left hand grips the vessel tightly by this detail the sculptor accentuated the weight of the “gift” the statue is holding.
A key element of this statues is the contrast in texture that we see between the water, and Godea himself. The shoulders of Godea along with the rest of him (excluding the head piece and inscriptions) are relatively smooth, and realistic. The dimple on the statues chin,curve of the lips and detailed lines of the eyebrows are made to look real, same with the feet and arms. This is in great contrast to the rivers of water that flow down both sides of his body.
The two streams of water that are spilling forth from the vessel held in the figures hands are very stylized. They are unrealistic to say the least. Fish can be seen jumping, adding to the water even more motion than was already given by the wavy stylishness of the water itself. The lines are well defined and stand out from the body of the statue, calling attention to its significance. The fish are also very stylized and less realistic then the rest of the figure. While Godea and the vessel are carved in the round (three-dimensional) the water and the fish are both flatter. Maybe only standing out half an inch or so, creating contrast and drawing attention.
The way that the figure may first catch your eyes with its upward stare and then as you follow the form to is center, it leads you back to the earth with water that is spilling forth, suggests sustainability, and abundance in resources. The gaze of the figure being focused upwards, while the feet remain grounded and surrounded by a downward flow of fish and water, signify to me a flow between heaven and earth. This flow is what enables votive statue of Godea to embody not only the position of devotion but also provision.

![]()
![]()
Woman of Willendorf
Initially the bulbous, hearty figure, and blunt sexuality of the Venus of Willendorf cause me to form a kinship with this image of a natural woman and to find beauty in her. She brings to mind a woman after childbirth. Her full breast, sagging abdomen, and swollen labia are suggestive of childbearing and the immediate after effects of birth, along with the red pigment that may have once covered her body. She appears soft and welcoming to a child. In the most primitive sense she proves her ability to nurture and provide with the voluptuousness of her body. She is such a natural woman, not idealized like we see today. Her breast are uneven, her body laden with fat, her buttocks are large and flat. She is the opposite of the feminine beauty widely recognized in our culture. The opposite of the image called forth by her given name “Venus”. This great separation between the my imaginative response to the name and the image that lies before me in this figurine, brings me to question how our idea of beauty has evolved, and what forces have fueled that evolution.
In the article TheVenus of Willendorf the author, Christopher L. C. E. Witcomb, suggests that by giving the figurine the name “Venus” we set her up for failure as far as fulfilling our expectations for beauty. The “Classical Venus” still defines beauty and femininity today. She is a thin woman in her prime. She has a beautiful face, perky breast, and a well defined abdomen and buttocks. Thus, when we hear “Venus of Willendorf” we may think of this statuesque figure of a goddess. Yet what we are met with is a fat, faceless, legless, and ageless woman small enough to be held in your hand.
While the “Classical Venus” is attractive in that ideal way that has been ingrained in all of us to recognize as beauty, she is also seductively modest. She isrefined or repressed depending on how you look at it, an element most certainly influenced by patriarchal societies. This image of a woman showing just enough to be sexy, a woman who seems to show no sign of her morality or repercussions of her reproductive function is still a prevalent ideology in our society. We are constantly faced with the paradox of a natural woman. Women, at least speaking for my self, want to recognize the beauty in all forms and stages of our woman hood, but are haunted by the images, experiences,, and products telling us the importance of maintaining the ideal.
The “Venus”, or perhaps more rightly named “Woman of Willendorf”, is the opposite of inhibition and refinement. Her sexuality just exists as a part of her. It is not dressed up, or shielded by any cultural expectations or taboos. Its impossible to know what the creator was trying to convey. I see a natural woman, a provider, encapsulated in a small intimate form. I myself think that this woman is beautiful and brave in her existence, causing reflection of my own refined sense of beauty and sexuality.
Introduction
Hello,
My name is Megan Gustafson, I am sophomore with no major yet. I just returned to school last winter after a 4 year break, which was spent traveling and building my lovely family. I have two children Opal, 3 years and Aristotle, “Ari”, 9 months. My loving husband Tyler is also in this course. We are both into music, gardening and hope to build a yurt within the next year or so. I am interested in art but don’t have much experience, just curiosity. I love yoga and am hoping to get my teaching certificate in the near future. Thats it for now.
Megan
